One of the problems with writing is the lead time which frequently makes the articles stale, if not out of date, by the time they are published.
AvePoint was close to releasing their new version while I was finishing the article but the magazine would only permit comparing released products.
Short version, somewhat updated:
Variables to consider:
- What backup solution do you have for the server operating system? And does it have a plug-in that recognizes SharePoint’s uniqueness? How granular is the restoration process for that backup solution? For instance, Backup Exec version that I examined could do a complete disaster recovery very well but could not restore individual items, lists, libraries, sites, etc. CommVault’s product could do both but would be expensive for a small shop and certainly overkill if you had already purchased a product to manage server backups.
- How big is your installation in database size and in number of servers, applications, site collections. There seemed to be no consistency in pricing. Some were per server, some per site collection or content database, etc.
- DocAve and SPDR were very user friendly, granular, and browser-based management. Disadvantage was that while they were great for all the SharePoint pieces, you still needed the IIS metabase and the custom files on the file system backed up by some other process. Still, the SharePoint admin could manage them without needing Network Admin or Server admin rights, which is another advantage for many shops.
I found comparing the products somewhat difficult because it was apples and oranges and bananas but fortunately, no lemons.